Close
MENU

Follow us on @Ask_ICAR for daily updates.

Home / Collision Repair News / If You Do What You've Always Done ...

If You Do What You've Always Done ...

Posted on 23 December 2014 | Share:
| Print Print

Ever hear the quote: "if you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always gotten"? When it comes to collision repairs, it's far from accurate.

Consider this situation, a 2025 car X had something hit it in the front right of the roof and push down the roof rail about an inch. This seems to be a small amount of damage but let's look a little deeper.

First, what material is the roof rail reinforcement made of? For this example, let's say it's 1,200 MPa. So it can't be heated or straightened. Next, is there a sectioning procedure? After researching the vehicle maker repair information there is no sectioning procedure available. At this point the correct way to fix this vehicle would to be replace the damaged roof rail reinforcement at a factory seam. This may seem like a rather intrusive repair but you need to look past what you would have done in the past.

If you decided to section this part, are you confident that your repair would withstand a rollover the same way it was originally designed? Was the part meant to transfer energy or start to absorb it? Did you strengthen or weaken the part, if so, how will that affect collision energy management? These types of questions need to be asked every time when considering how to repair a vehicle. If in the end the decision is made to fix the vehicle without a vehicle maker repair procedure, then the full burden falls to those who decided to repair the vehicle without any documentation.


Article validated in 2024

  • App-Based Connected Services Considerations: Toyota/Lexus Thursday, 15 January 2026

    Have you had the experience where the vehicle notified the owner that it was being moved while it was in your repair facility? App-based connected services are available from many vehicle makers and may...

  • Digital Key Considerations: Toyota/Lexus Thursday, 15 January 2026

    The intermingling of technology and automobiles continues, with digital key offerings from most vehicle makers. Digital keys utilize smartphone technology to expand vehicle access and owner...

  • Nissan/INFINITI Position Statements: Advanced Driver Assistance System Components Thursday, 8 January 2026

    Nissan/INFINITI released position statements on the use of salvaged, aftermarket, and "secondary-market" advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) components.

  • I-CAR Repairers Realm: RTS 2025 Year In Review - Now Available Tuesday, 6 January 2026

    I-CAR had a discussion on the Repairability Technical Support (RTS) 2025 year in review.

  • Ford On Target 2025: Volume 4 Monday, 5 January 2026

    Ford has released the fourth installment of their On Target publication for 2025.

  • Structural Sectioning Procedures: Ford/Lincoln - UPDATE Friday, 19 December 2025

    Ask I-CAR receives many technical inquiries referring to sectioning. The collision repair industry wants to know where can you section, does the OEM have a sectioning procedure, and where can I find the...

  • Body Repair Manual Symbols: Hyundai Wednesday, 17 December 2025

    While looking at repair procedures in a body repair manual (BRM) you may notice that symbols are used to indicate specific operations or parts to be used during the repair process. Most BRMs provide a...

  • Body Repair Manual Symbols: Genesis Wednesday, 17 December 2025

    While looking at repair procedures in a body repair manual (BRM) you may notice that symbols are used to indicate specific operations or parts to be used during the repair process. Most BRMs provide a...

  • App-Based Connected Services Considerations: BMW Wednesday, 10 December 2025

    Have you had an experience where the vehicle notified the owner that it was being moved while it was in your repair facility? App-based connected services are available from many vehicle makers and...

  • Digital Key Considerations: BMW Wednesday, 10 December 2025

    The intermingling of technology and automobiles continues, with digital key offerings from most vehicle makers. Digital keys utilize smartphone technology to expand vehicle access and owner...

Top Ten Vehicle Specific Questions

Hyundai Does Hyundai have a sectioning procedure available?
2014 Jeep CherokeeIs there a procedure available for resetting the active headrestt?
Kia Does Kia have a sectioning procedure available?
Chevrolet Does Chevrolet have a warning against sectioning when there is no procedure?
BMW Can I-CAR send me BMW repair procedures?
Honda What does Honda say about repairing damaged SRS wiring harnesses?
Hyundai Does Hyundai have part replacement procedures available?
Mercedes-Benz Can I-CAR send me Mercedes-Benz repair procedures?
Honda What does Honda say about straightening front lower rails?
Subaru Do you have to replace a front passenger airbag on a Subaru even if the airbag did not deploy? The repair information seems to indicate that it should.

Top Ten I-CAR Specific Questions

What does I-CAR say about using a recycled quarter panel assembly that includes the inner, outer, and reinforcements?
What does I-CAR say about repair tolerances?
What does I-CAR say about replacing suspension parts in pairs?
What does I-CAR say about straightening a kink?
What does I-CAR say about the decision to use recycled parts?
What does I-CAR say about repairing damaged door intrusion beams?
Can I-CAR General Sectioning Guidelines be used?
What does I-CAR say about repairing damaged bumper reinforcements?
What does I-CAR say about disconnecting the battery prior to welding on the vehicle, specifically in regards to airbags?
What does I-CAR say about using recycled airbags?